Log in

No account? Create an account
06 June 2009 @ 04:57 pm
movie comment: a definite thumbs up for UP!  
I went and saw UP with the kids today, and we all enjoyed it tremendously. As is always the strength with a Pixar movie, the characters were incredibly appealing and felt real (even the talking dogs). For complexity of character and pure character arc, I don't think UP was as strong as THE INCREDIBLES or TOY STORY or even WALL-E. But I will say that I laughed out loud multiple times at humor that did feel derived from character and did not consist of unrealistic smart-mouth-screenwriter lines. I especially compliment the writing for Russell, who felt like a nine-year-old kid in terms of dialogue.

I thought the script relied a little bit more on gimmicks and had a shade more preposterousness than other Pixar flicks, but of course when you're talking about dogs flying airplanes, and a lost land in South America, and floating a house around by having it tied (with string) to a bunch of balloons you're already well into the land of speculative. Some of the stunts were a little hard to believe, but again, it's a freaking floating house!

Another strength of Pixar's storytelling is how there are little things in the plot that come back later or explain things without having to explain them. Examples here are: "Squirrel!", the tennis balls on the cane, the names of the dogs, the squeaky collar, the helium tanks in the front yard, and the GPS (which was used then conveniently resolved). There's plenty more as well.

Overall, a highly enjoyable movie that I would recommend to all ages. It's the second week but the theatre was packed with families, which is a good sign that the movie will have some serious legs and keep Pixar in the movie-making business for some time to come. Which is a good thing for all concerned!
Tags: ,
jeffsoesbe: yeff southparkjeffsoesbe on June 9th, 2009 03:30 am (UTC)
It was indeed fun, and I was touched and dewy-eyed during the opening montage. I also laughed out loud many times, especially in scenes with Dug and with Russell.